Skip to main content

Think to write or write to think?

Writing is essentially both an interpersonal communication (in which one thinks to write) and an intrapersonal communication (in which one writes to think)

The concepts available in the literature about the nature of writing seem to be polarized into two opposing poles. One the one hand, writing is viewed as the process of communicating messages (thoughts, emotions, or feelings) in a readable form using written language symbols (letters, punctuation, and spaces). In short, he first thinks and then writes. On the other hand, writing is viewed as a thinking process. In this paradigm, writing is seen as a process for clarifying, not simply communicating thinking. These two opposing views have made the question of whether we think first and write or write first and then think as difficult as to answer the old ‘chicken and egg’ issue. This article aims to determine which of these views is closest to the nature of writing by examining what happens in a real writing process.

The proponents of the view that writing is the process of communicating messages in readable texts commonly argue that whether a person writes using a pen/pencil (handwriting) or a keyboard (typing), he begins by thinking of ideas and then writes them down. Since the final text contains the writer’s thoughts, sharing it with the intended audience indicates that writing, like speaking, is interpersonal communication. In line with this view, Rivers (1968), a well-known language teaching methodologist, stated that writing refers to the expression of ideas in a systematic way to organize the graphic conventions of the language. The famous writer Richard Wright also supports this by saying that while writing, he was trying to build a bridge of words between him and that world outside. This metaphor indicates that writing is conveying or communicating messages to the reader (the world outside) through written words.

Those who view writing as a thinking process argue that while writing, one is essentially trying to discover his thoughts by conducting an intra-personal communication. White and Arndt (1991) stated: “Writing is far from being a simple matter of transcribing language into written symbols: it is a thinking process in its own right.” In line with this, Hunt (2010) stated that writing is not just expressing ideas that have previously been in mind, but also a magical and mysterious process that allows the author to construct (make) new or different ideas Thus, in writing, a person writes first and then thinks. Reflecting on his experiences as a writer, William Stafford accentuated, "I don't see writing as communication of something already discovered, as 'truths' already known. Rather, I see writing as a job of experiment. It's like any discovery job; you don't know what's going to happen until you try it."

To ensure which view is more accurate, checking what happens in a real writing process seems to be the most reasonable way. According to Time4writing.com (n.d.), the process of writing consists of five stages: prewriting, drafting, revising, editing, and publishing. Prewriting includes the activities of generating, selecting, sorting, and organizing ideas to write about. It also involves the consideration of purpose and target audience which will affect the genre selection and organization. Drafting comprises the recording of ideas intended to meaning-making, grammar, spelling, and punctuation. Revising is conducted to review, modify, reorganize the text by deleting, adding, or rearranging content and by suiting the tone, style, and content to the target audience. Peers and/or instructor’s feedback is often beneficial to help improve the writing. Editing is carried out to proofread and correct grammatical and mechanical errors. It also involves efforts to improve style and clarity. Publishing refers to the preparation for sharing the text with the target audience.


As shown by Figure 1, the writing process is not linear but recursive. It doubles back upon itself and leaps ahead. While drafting, for instance, it’s possible that a writer also directly corrects a grammatical error. Thus, he has proofread (a later stage). In Figure 1, the red arrows indicate a first forward move; the green arrows represent a backward move; and the purple arrows indicate a second forward move, i.e., you go to the revising stage again after returning a while to the drafting stage.

Now let’s see these stages in action. Suppose you are going to write about Lake Toba in an essay of about 600 words in length. To a higher extent, the first thing you do is to try to consider the most interesting subject related to Lake Toba that you can write well in about six to seven paragraphs. Then, you brainstorm to generate ideas, make an outline, and do research by reading relevant sources or interviewing people familiar with the subject. After that, you write the draft, revise it, edit it, and finally publish the final text.

Considering these activities, it is clear that thinking and writing take place concurrently during the writing process. While considering the topic, you are thinking. In brainstorming, you generate ideas by writing them so that they are visible, and their visibility enables you to observe and refine them. You also involve both while outlining and researching. In drafting, you express the points you have organized in the outline into sentences and paragraphs. Although these activities are predominated by the activity of putting down ideas into written symbols, your thinking is also involved to make sure the outline is systematic. In revising you improve your draft by adding, removing, rearranging, and replacing information. These activities also involve both writing and thinking. In editing, in which you proofread and correct any errors to make the essay clear and interesting to read, both writing and thinking are involved.

In conclusion, the writing process simultaneously involves thinking and writing. One cannot write without employing both of them. He needs to think to construct ideas and to write to put and organize them in written form. By having the ideas in written forms, they are visible and easy to refine (by thinking). The refined ideas are then communicated (by writing) in a readable written language so that the target audience can get what you mean. Think, write, think, and write are simultaneous activities you conduct in writing. Thus, writing is essentially both an interpersonal communication (in which one thinks to write) and an intrapersonal communication (in which one writes to think).


Author: Parlindungan Pardede (parlin@weedutap.com)

Comments

  1. I agree with the thesis of this article. Writing is thinking. When writing an essay or article, I usually find the ideas in my mind are not enough to support my points. I found brainstorming with others gives me valuable enrichment. Reading relevant works by others are also helpful, as I can cite their ideas.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yeah, writing and thinking are two inseparable things. But I personally more often and comfortable with thinking first and then writing, either from one's own thoughts or feedback from others.
    And I personally was at first confused about the writing process as above, but because my lecturer often gave assignments to write paragraphs and essays, I began to get used to the writing process above (although sometimes there are still wrong).
    From there I learned that the writing process can be understood if you practice writing a lot and a long process.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with this article. writing is essentially both an interpersonal communication (in which one thinks to write) and an intrapersonal communication (in which one writes to think). But for me, I more often thinking first, and then writing, for example like when I want write my diary book I will think firs about what I will write and then read again to revise it. From this article I got point that is we needs to think to construct ideas and to write to put and organize them in written form, and writing essay is a process to practice our skill to be a good writer and critical.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Alright, I strongly agree with the article. For me, thinking is the first thing that I do than writing. Why?, because when I write an essay, story, etc, I think first about the title and process of writing. After that, I write the ideas in my mind through writing process.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Esensi Umpan Balik dalam Pembelajaran Daring

Untuk mengoptimalkan pembelajaran daring (online learning), komitmen untuk bertukar umpan balik merupakan keharusan. Bertukar umpan balik tidak hanya mengatasi perasaan terisolasi, kesulitan berkonsentrasi, dan kesulitan untuk terlibat dalam pembelajaran tetapi juga meningkatkan capaian pembelajaran dan mengembangkan 4C. Sebagai bagian dari upaya mencegah penyebaran virus corona, sekolah-sekolah di semua jenjang pendidikan di hampir seluruh dunia telah ditutup. Pada tanggal 30 April 2020, lebih dari 1,2 miliar siswa di 182 negara ditugaskan belajar dari rumah. Sebagian besar menerapkan pembelajaran daring (dalam jaringan), dan sebagian lagi menggunakan pembelajaran luring (luar jaringan). Pembelajaran daring pada dasarnya bukan praktik baru. Begitu mulai digunakan pada akhir 1980-an, jumlah pelajar, khususnya di perguruan tinggi, yang mengikuti pembelajaran daring terus meningkat. Pada tahun 2018, lebih dari seperempat mahasiswa di AS mengambil kelas daring. Sebelum COVID 19 mere

An Analysis of the Theme and Plot of "A Long Walk Home"

  An Analysis of the Theme and Plot of   A Long Walk Home Summary of the Short Story Boccaro’s  A Long walk Home  is a short story that tells how Jackson, a teen with a delinquent tendency, grows wiser after experiencing a bitter experience with his father. It begins when one morning Jackson is asked to have his father’s car repaired in a garage 18 miles away from their home on condition that when the car is finished, Jackson should pick his father at 4 p.m. since the car requires a few hours to be serviced, after dropping of it to the garage, he watches some movies up to 6 p.m. To avoid his father from getting angry for his being late, Jackson says that it takes long to repair the car without realizing that his father has phoned the garage and knows there’s no problem with the car. Jackson’s lie makes his father angry to himself for his failure to educate his son. So he refuses to get into the car and walks home. This makes Jackson very regretful and decides not to lie to his father e

Flipped Classroom: Model Pembelajaran Campuran yang Efektif

Pendahuluan Flipped classroom adalah inovasi metode pembelajaran terbaru di era dijital. Metode ini merupakan salah satu model blended learning yang begitu efektif hingga para pendidik yang sedang mempersiapkan diri melaksanakan blended learning direkomendasikan untuk menggunakannya. Penelitian mengungkapkan metode ini sangat efektif untuk mengubah siswa dari pasif menjadi menjadi aktif, dari pembelajar yang ‘ogah-ogahan’ menjadi bertanggungjawab untuk menguasai konten pembelajaran, karena metode ini mengaktivasi dan mengembangkan keterampilan berpikir siswa, baik secara mandiri maupun kolaboratif. Dengan metode ini, guru lebih berperan sebagai fasilitator, pembimbing dan motivator.  Hakikat Flipped Classroom Sesuai dengan namanya, ‘flipped’, yang bermakna ‘membalikkan pola, posisi, urutan, susunan, atau arah sesuatu, flipped classroom merupakan metode pembelajaran yang membalikkan atau mengubah pola pembelajaran tradisional. Karena kata ‘flipped’ bersinonim dengan ‘inverted’