Skip to main content

A Lesson from Six Great Autodidacts: Learning is Good, Schooling is Bad.

College education has long been the most common way of making one educated and shaping a better life. But many college graduates today cannot thrive in life because they were merely schooling, not learning while going to college.

Going through social distancing due to COVID 19 for about a month, I found reading very effective to help me manage stay-at-home recommendations. Being not so obliged to interact as intensively as I used to with the outside world, I have greater opportunity to read new books and articles online or reread dusty books that have been kept on the shelf. Some books I found interesting were the biographies of Abraham Lincoln, Mark Twain, Thomas Alfa Edison, Sri Pudjiastuti, Bill Gates, and Mark Zuckerberg. One of the reasons is that they teach me three similar interesting facts concerning education.

First of all, these six great figures either attended very little formal school or did not graduate from college. Lincoln attended formal school only for about twelve months because the school in his era was still rare as he was brought in the frontier. Twain quitted from elementary school when he was twelve years old because he saw the school system in his era lacked education and learning. Edison attended public school only in 12 weeks. He was considered "difficult" by his teacher due to his hyperactivity. Pudjiastuti dropped out from the third grade of senior high school due to her involvement in “golongan putih” political movement. Bill Gates and Mark Zuckerberg dropped out in different eras from Harvard University because they wanted to focus on chasing their dreams in creating computer programs.


Although they quitted school at different levels and for different reasons, they all do one important thing, which designates their second similarity, i.e. they read a lot to keep educating themselves. Lincoln kept on learning by reading and reflecting on his life experiences. Twain, while working as a printer in various cities, learned by spending every night reading at the public libraries. Concerning the importance of reading, he once said: "The man who does not read books has no advantage over the man that cannot read them." Expelled from schools, Edison was taught by his mother at home. His voracious appetite for knowledge and high eagerness to read books on various subjects emerged when he was 11 years old. He once said how thankful he was to his mother who thought him reading which “opened up a great world in literature”. Gates and Zuckerberg are also avid readers and are disciplined about it. According to Gates, Reading is still the main way that I both learn new things and test my understanding.” Up to now, he keeps on blocking at least an hour a day to read so he can finish reading a book per week.  For Zuckerberg, reading is a means to explore “new cultures, beliefs, histories, and technologies". He states, “Books allow you to fully explore a topic and immerse yourself in a deeper way than most media today.”

Third, all of them focus on achieving their goals. They dedicate their attention and energy to develop the fields they are interested in. When they were not able yet to attain their goals, they increase their capacities, improve their skills, and enlarge their knowledge to find the correct way to achieve their goals. Before serving as the 16th US president, he ever worked as a boatman, store clerk, surveyor, militia soldier, and a lawyer in Illinois. As a politician, he even lost eight elections, but he never gave up on improving himself. Mark Twain worked hard as a printer in various cities before traveling across America and wrote the works that make him the father of American literature. Edison began to sell newspapers to passengers along the Grand Trunk Railroad line when he was 12 and began to make scientific experiments in his laboratory. He is very well known for his hard-work ethic and perseverance. That’s why he was never discouraged by failures. He believed that “Many of life's failures are people who did not realize how close they were to success when they gave up." With his 1093 patents, he became the greatest inventor of the 20th century.

Staying focus on one’s mission is also obvious in Pudjiatuti, Gates, and Zuckerberg’s life. Quitting from school, Pudjiastuti began to be a seafood distributor. Despite the various adversities she met, she evolved her business to a seafood processing and established “Susi Air” to transport her fresh seafood to some countries. In 2014 she was appointed by President Jokowi as Minister of Marine Affairs and Fisheries. Leaving Harvard Gates focused on developing computer software, and his Microsoft Corp founded with Paul Allen becomes the leading software company in the world. Zuckerberg launched Facebook in 2004 and decided to leave Harvard University to move to Palo Alto, California, to work on the new program with his friends. The success of Facebook made him named Time Magazine’s Person of the Year in 2010.

What is the relevancy of these three points—attending very little formal school or quitting from college, reading a lot to keep on educating, and focusing on achieving one’s goal—to education? Well, the lives of those six great people reveal that although they got only a “moderate formal schooling” or did not get a college degree, life-long learning made them successful. They are great autodidacts.

Does this mean that getting a college degree is not important? Don’t get me wrong. Going to college is essential in helping us determine and shape our future. Colleges promote learning by exposing various subjects, activities, ideas, and tools that students would probably not find anywhere else. Colleges also provide lecturers to guide and encourage students during the process of acquiring and developing knowledge, skills, and wisdom. The importance of colleges has been proven by the fact that many people have managed to climb up the ladders after graduating from college. Attending college has long been the main way for most people to be educated and to thrive in life. But it is not the only way.

However, due to the various changes occurring along the last decades, just attending a college, fulfilling the formal schooling requirements, and getting a degree are no more sufficient for getting a good job and a better life. According to most employers, current college graduates do not have the skills necessary for the workforce. They feel that college students lack professionalism, work ethic, problem-solving, and leadership skills among others. A recent study revealed only 16% of Americans believe that a four-year degree prepares students very well for a well-paying job in today’s economy and 51% think this type of degree prepares students “somewhat well” for the workplace. In Australia, the proportion of new university graduates in full-time employment has dropped from 56.4% to 41.7% in 2008 to 2014. In Singapore, four in ten graduates can’t find full-time work. In Indonesia, almost 6% of the total number of unemployed people were university graduates, but Willis Towers Watson's study revealed that since 2014, 8 from 10 top companies in the country find it difficult to recruit the graduates who meet the qualification according to the companies' needs.

Two major factors make college fresh graduates fail to meet the requirements of the current workforce. First, colleges do not regularly reform their curricula. A recent study reported that around 60-70% of today’s students are being educated in jobs that won’t exist by the time they graduate. As a consequence, the skills gap between what colleges are educating and the needs of the market always occurs.

No college can indeed provide their students with the exact knowledge and skills required by business and employers at the time they graduate. However, merely facilitating students to acquire discipline-specific knowledge and skills is not enough. Through an appropriate curriculum and learning system, every college should equip the students with critical soft skills future markets would demand, like people skills, resilience, empathy, and integrity, innovation, and creativity.

The second and more influential factor is that many students misunderstand (even misvalue) the true meaning of education. In their view, college education concerns merely with attending a university for getting a degree with as high as possible GPA. In their mind, if they can pass the examination of every subject offered in the curriculum, that's enough. So, getting good grades is the endgame of every learning activity. In this case, the students are merely schooling, i.e. acquiring the academic knowledge and skills required to pass an examination. To make it worse, some students just tried to quickly memorize information through repetition (cramming) for the exams and do not care if they soon forget it after finishing the exam. Although cramming can be used to help develop foundational knowledge or to quickly recall pieces of information, it does not allow involve higher-order thinking as students do not try to relate the new and the previous knowledge. It also discourages social skills use. As a result, cramming does not facilitate a deeper understanding nor hone creativity.

Passing examinations essentially does not make one educated. To be educated, every student should develop his ‘whole person’, not only knowledge and skills, through learning. Learning is an ongoing process to adopt new information and skills obtained from new experiences, relate it to previously acquired knowledge and skills, and adapt it into various dynamic circumstances. This definition indicates that learning is not merely to memorize information. It is neither a fragmentary or sporadic activity. It is a continuous activity in which we involved our whole being (thought, emotion, muscles, and senses) to get new experiences and transform the experience into information which is adopted to increase the knowledge and skills we have got and employ the updated knowledge and skills to solve problems we encounter and make improvement in our life. Thus, learning is not merely knowing but also being able to use and adapt new knowledge and skills in various contexts of life.

The definition above designates that our experiences are the source of the new knowledge and skills we learned. The experiences can be obtained through reading, interactions with other people, observation, or experiments. This indicates that the richer our experiences the higher the quality of our new knowledge and skills will be. That is why one’s engagement is very crucial in true learning. The Centre for Creative Leadership 70:20:10 model for learning and development suggests that 70% of development occurs through the actions of the individual, 20% through relationships, and only 10% through classroom activities. Thus, to succeed in learning, one needs to optimize his individual learning activities (reading, taking notes, summarizing, researching, etc.) as they contribute most. Classroom activities contribute only 10% to learning.

Different from schooling which is relatively easy because students merely trying to pass examinations and get good grades, learning is effortful. Students who are schooling tend to lose interest in learning. They usually try to find the easiest possible ways to finish assignments. Rather than reading the assigned textbooks, they just skim a summary or a book review. If they have alternatives, they choose to write an essay or do a project on a familiar topic and sign up easier classes with less challenging lecturers. Consequently, their thinking quality, perseverance, and desire to do the best never develop.

On the other hand, students who are learning are willing to meet new challenges and ready to take risks in their education. Instead of merely fulfilling the objectives of their course syllabi, they go further by studying various additional sources, relating one subject to another, or creating more sophisticated projects. They know that their hard-works will not just produce good grades but also hone their thinking and innovative skills, increase their people skills, produce a feeling of accomplishment which eventually boosts their resilience and integrity, and enhance their creativity. In short, learning is essentially far more effortful but rewarding than schooling.

To conclude, to be educated and successful, one should learn, not merely go to school. Learning can be conducted inside or outside of school. Lincoln, Twain, Edison, Pudjiastuti, Gates, and Zuckerberg are well educated and successful although they are not at school. They are autodidacts. They commit to continuously learn. Many college graduates are well educated and successful, but many others failed.  The difference is that the former learn when they were at college, while the latter just did schooling. Schooling can probably enable one to pass examinations and get a degree, but it does not develop knowledge, thinking skills, social skills, and creativity. It is learning, not grades or a degree that matters.

Do you agree with this article? If you are now a college student, are you schooling or learning? We’d like to hear from you. Please write your views in the comments section below.


Author : Parlindungan Pardede (parlin@weedutap.com)

Comments

  1. Impressive!
    I got two things that interest, schooling and not schooling. Schooling for they who want to get the score and title .

    Learn and develop themselves is the priority one from people who not schooling. In passed period skor and title is the concern people who want to get the best opportunity to get the job. People who are got the low score and don't get the title they will not have the chance to get the job. But ,today even though you have the title or good score you're not accepting in job field. Because , the concern now is the soft skills . The main from skills is we learn by ourselves. Even though the school prepared everything for us I think they just facilitate us.

    One thing more interest is learning can be conducted inside or outside of school. I believe they are autodidacts can change their life become a good one. Learn by ourselves is the key for get successful.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree and also interested to this article. " learning is good, schooling is bad". When I read the title of the article, I'm confused. It 's because, I think learning same with schooling. But, after I finish reading this article, I understand why learning is good and schooling is bad.

    Learning can develop our knowledge, thinking skills, social skills, and creativity. Meanwhile, schooling just help us to pass examinations and get a degree or another word schooling just to facilate our learning.
    For me personally, I want learning not schooling. So, when I graduated from University, I has knowledge, thinking skills, and creativity not only get a degree.
    " Learn more important than school". You can learn in anytime and anywhere.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I strongly agree with this article that a high degree is not a benchmark to judge whether someone is educated or not. Thankfully there are many people who can prove this thing like Licoln, Twain, Edison, Bill Gates, Mark Zuckerberg, and Susi Pudjiastuti who show that without a high degree they still can become people who are even more educated compared to some people with higher degrees .
    Here are three interesting things that I got from reading this article.

    First is that in getting a degree, students now tend to do schooling rather than learning which is a fact that I can see around me. They tend to only focus on getting high grades that they don't even care about completing their assignments. This makes them choose to do a copy and paste or recruit others to complete their assignments, and choose to cheat during exams by opening books or cellphones in answering important questions. They don't care about the progress in learning, as long as they get a high scores which makes their score is not match with the knowledge they have.

    The second is that learning is gained from experience. Just like everyone like the example above who show us that before they become successful people, they have a lot of experiences that gives them a lot of lessons by combining their previous knowledge with the latest knowledge they got.

    And the last is that 70% of development occurs through individual actions. I strongly agree with this, that no matter how good the education or the educators are, if the person himself does not have the will to learn then every development will not occur.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I strongly agree with this article, because learning adds to our knowledge or insight, while schools get a degree and one of the requirements for education. To learn, we can get it anywhere, but we don't have to study at school, even at school, just playing with friends. Learning today is very important, because if we have a lot of knowledge, we can apply it in our lives.

    ReplyDelete
  5. From this title I have been interested to read it. I totally agree with the author, especially in the section: "No college can indeed provide their students with the exact knowledge and skills required by business and employers at the time they graduate." It means that the students are more active in developing their potential. Because the campus or school is only facilitating students in learning. The task as a student is to study deeper. Especially now that there is technology that is very possible to improve students' abilities.
    Hopefully, all the students more be active like the great figure told above.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  7. awesome! I strongly agree with this article when to be educated and successful, one should learn, not merely going to school. Learning can be conducted inside or outside of school.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Good, I agree with you, and I realize that learning is infinity, we can learn everything, every time, and everywhere.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I agree with this article completely. When I read this article, I think why schooling become such a bad thing, because some people think of it as a competitive ground. Being in a college or having a high education may not guarantee a person's learning will succeed. We can see through the great men featured by this article, Abraham Lincoln, Mark Twain, Bill Gates, Thomas alfa Edison, sri pudjiastuti, and mark zuckkerberg. Furthermore, the interesting thing I found through this article is that the real learning we can find through every experience and interaction with others, it shows we can actually learn from anywhere and at any time. Another interesting thing I like, soft skills being one of the indicators that everyone should have. Like the examples of the above, their skills (creativity, innovation and empathy) prove that they can still learn new things even when they have failed in school.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I agree with this article. After I read this article, I got some interesting things, which are:

    1. The six figures prove that someone is said to be educated not only if they go to school. They prove it with the intention and hard work to learn so they can succeed. They learn self-taught by only reading books and through their life experiences. They also focus on what they aspire to. Continue to improve the skills they have.

    2. I realize that someone's involvement is very important in our learning process. With others we can share information and experiences that we never could. So that our knowledge and experience increases.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I strongly agree with this article. I think I will choose learning than schooling, because if I learn I am willing to meet new challenges and ready to take risks in education not only that, learning makes us able to develop knowledge, thinking skills, social skills, and creativity. But if I choose schooling it just can enable one to pass examinations and get a degree and don't get any interest to learn. That's why I choose learning.

    And two things that I got from this article. The first is reading a lot can make us have more knowledge and more confidence. The last is we can learn in everywhere and every time, because learning is unlimited so we can learn until we die.

    ReplyDelete
  12. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I am very interested in this article. in my opinion self-study and study in school helps us in developing knowledge. I think by studying on our own we can develop the knowledge we know and get. because by studying alone I accept new challenges and be ready to take risks in education. not only that, learning allows us to develop knowledge, thinking skills, social skills, and creativity.
    But on the one hand, we also have to stay in school, maybe some students can not know much. And in my opinion, schools can also help us to gain knowledge. The most important thing is the intention of ourselves that we will take to reach it, we will take it, but if we are unable, there will be help coming to us.
    and there are two things that make me understand what it means to read in life. The first reading a lot makes us have more knowledge and more confidence. Finally, we can study anywhere and anytime, because learning is unlimited so we can learn until we die.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

In times of Coronavirus pandemic, we can make a difference.

Practicing kindness to others not only enables us to make a difference but also makes us happier and stimulates others to perform kindness.
COVID 19 hit the world by surprise and is quickly spreading like wildfire across the globe. Up to the time this article was written, it has been infecting more than 3 million people, causing more than 200,000 deaths, and sending billions of people into the stay at home or lockdown to help 'flatten the curve' of infections. And since it is a new virus, we now have only relatively limited information about it and there is no yet vaccine or preventative treatment for it. Having limited knowledge and seeing its devastating effects, it is understandable why people are anxious and frightening. 

What can we do in such a critical moment? Should we just let our governments do everything? No! Precisely while facing a radical crisis and when survival is threatened by an insurmountable problem that we have a great opportunity to do good to make a differ…

Flipped Classroom: Model Pembelajaran Campuran yang Efektif

Pendahuluan
Flipped classroom adalah inovasi metode pembelajaran terbaru di era dijital. Metode ini merupakan salah satu model blended learning yang begitu efektif hingga para pendidik yang sedang mempersiapkan diri melaksanakan blended learning direkomendasikan untuk menggunakannya. Penelitian mengungkapkan metode ini sangat efektif untuk mengubah siswa dari pasif menjadi menjadi aktif, dari pembelajar yang ‘ogah-ogahan’ menjadi bertanggungjawab untuk menguasai konten pembelajaran, karena metode ini mengaktivasi dan mengembangkan keterampilan berpikir siswa, baik secara mandiri maupun kolaboratif. Dengan metode ini, guru lebih berperan sebagai fasilitator, pembimbing dan motivator. 

Hakikat Flipped Classroom Sesuai dengan namanya, ‘flipped’, yang bermakna ‘membalikkan pola, posisi, urutan, susunan, atau arah sesuatu, flipped classroom merupakan metode pembelajaran yang membalikkan atau mengubah pola pembelajaran tradisional. Karena kata ‘flipped’ bersinonim dengan ‘inverted’, flipped cl…

Terrorized by Coronavirus Pandemic: Do we need Superheroes?

We need superheroes because their role models motivate us to be aware that any of us is capable of becoming a superhero, and by collaborating, we can fight any disaster that threats the world.
The coronavirus hit the world by surprise and keeps on spreading like wildfire across the globe. Only in four months, it has been affecting more than 200 countries and territories around the world, infecting more than 2 million people and killed more than 140,000. To limit the number of people’s exposure to the virus to slow down its spread, some countries or zones are locked down, offices, schools, and public places are shut, and our lives are on hold. Many people are despondent because they cannot meet their beloved ones. Some others are depressed about being unable to do the routines they used to have. Some even think their freedom is robbed.

The sheer terror and horror of this fast-moving infection are intensified when we hear that the number of death it causes keeps on increasing so sharply t…